Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi are two of Star Wars’ strongest Jedi and two of Star Wars’ finest characters—however who was actually extra expert? Anakin/Darth Vader and Obi-Wan have now had a number of showdowns in Star Wars films and TV reveals, together with in Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, A New Hope, and Obi-Wan Kenobi. Anakin/Vader’s power and uncooked energy are simple, particularly given he’s the Chosen One, but Obi-Wan has nearly all the time come out on prime.

Obi-Wan clearly beat out Vader in Revenge of the Sith, given he left him almost for useless, a lot in order that he had really believed Anakin was useless after Mustafar. In Obi-Wan Kenobi, Vader bested Obi-Wan initially, however in the long run, he was defeated by Obi-Wan as soon as extra. Even in A New Hope, Vader does not actually kill Obi-Wan; Obi-Wan turns into one with the Power earlier than he’s struck down. With Anakin’s uncooked energy and Obi-Wan’s pretty constant profitable report, the query stays: who was extra expert between Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader?

Anakin Was Undeniably Extra Highly effective—However Energy Would not Equal Ability

As The Chosen One, Anakin Had Immense Uncooked Energy

Anakin Skywalker was not solely some of the highly effective Jedi, but additionally, as Darth Vader, he turned certainly one of Star Wars’ strongest Sith. Whereas Obi-Wan could have been robust within the Power in his personal proper, he definitely does not beat Anakin/Vader when it comes to energy. Energy does not routinely equate to ability, although. Whereas Anakin could have Obi-Wan beat when it comes to energy, Obi-Wan was all the time extra expert than Anakin.

Partly, this will have been as a result of timing of Anakin’s fall to the darkish facet. Sure, Anakin had accomplished his Jedi coaching by the point he turned Darth Vader, however Obi-Wan had many extra years beneath his belt as a Jedi. As soon as Anakin turned Darth Vader, his abilities additionally modified, if not outright halted, due to the constraints of his swimsuit. Vader clearly continued to be a formidable opponent, however he needed to adapt to the restrictive and painful Vader swimsuit.

Obi-Wan Kenobi Was Extra Disciplined

Obi-Wan Kenobi Was Recognized For Being A Dependable, Degree-Headed Jedi

Even with Obi-Wan’s longer time as a Jedi apart, Obi-Wan was merely extra disciplined than Anakin when it comes to character. Whereas Anakin was passionate and would act first and assume later, Obi-Wan was nearly all the time calm, rational, and centered. He was the truth is identified within the Jedi Order for his self-discipline and knowledge, with even different members of the Jedi Council seeking to him for solutions at occasions.

That dynamic was even clear with Obi-Wan’s personal former Jedi Grasp, Qui-Gon Jinn. Qui-Gon’s nature was way more like Anakin’s than Obi-Wan’s, and he was typically cussed and prepared to interrupt the foundations if he felt that was the fitting factor to do. In distinction, Obi-Wan was devoted to the Jedi method. Whereas that does not essentially imply a higher stage of ability, in Obi-Wan’s case it did, as he was in a position to stay centered and devoted to creating his abilities and trusting within the Power.

Associated

I Suppose Star Wars Made A Massive Mistake Killing Qui-Gon In The Phantom Menace

The demise of Qui-Gon Jinn in The Phantom Menace was an necessary a part of Anakin Skywalker’s story, however I actually assume it was an enormous mistake.

Obi-Wan’s Lightsaber Expertise And Preventing Fashion Had been Larger Than Anakin’s

As a result of He Was Extra Disciplined, Obi-Wan Was The Higher Duelist

This self-discipline that Obi-Wan had translated on to his abilities with a lightsaber and in battle. Too typically, Anakin ran head-first right into a battle with out a clear plan, which led to his seize greater than as soon as and was the rationale he misplaced his hand to Rely Dooku. The identical was true of his battle with Obi-Wan Kenobi on Mustafar. Obi-Wan explicitly warned Anakin to not strive leaping when Obi-Wan had the excessive floor. Anakin was, in his personal phrases, unable to be rational, nevertheless, and it value him all his remaining flesh limbs and almost his life.

Obi-Wan’s levelheadedness and ability in battle are in flip why he was in a position to defeat Darth Maul in Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace earlier than he was even actually a full-fledged Jedi. They’re additionally why he defeated each Common Grievous and Anakin/Vader single-handedly in Revenge of the Sith. In all three circumstances, extra than simply uncooked energy (though Obi-Wan had loads of that as properly), Obi-Wan was strategic, which was a significant component in his victory.

It is also notable that the Duel of the Fates battle in The Phantom Menace and the Mustafar battle in Revenge of the Sith are thought-about two of Star Wars’ finest lightsaber duels. Each battles concerned Obi-Wan, suggesting that his lightsaber abilities are higher than most. In fact, lightsaber abilities should not the one necessary ability set in Star Wars.

Anakin Was Expert In Sure Methods, However He Was By no means Extra Expert Than Obi-Wan

Anakin Was An Unimaginable Pilot And Possessed Different Expertise

Obi-Wan did not have the higher hand on each single Jedi/Power ability. Anakin was unquestionably the higher pilot, for instance, and he had mastered some unimaginable Power powers that Obi-Wan does not appear to have ever had, together with when he was in a position to switch the Daughter’s remaining life essence into Ahsoka within the Mortis Gods arc in Star Wars: The Clone Wars. In that sense, there is not an easy reply.

Associated

Mortis Gods Defined: Star Wars Historical past, Powers, Planet & Significance

The Mortis gods are a few of Star Wars’ strongest Power-wielders, and Dave Filoni is utilizing them to unite The Clone Wars, Rebels, and now Ahsoka.

There’s additionally been some discourse relating to how Star Wars measures coaching and ability. On the YouTube channel Star Wars Principle, visitor Nick Gillard defined that, in his view, George Lucas had imagined a scale of 10—though, nobody ever reached 10. With coaching, one might transfer incrementally up that scale. Nonetheless, as has lengthy been proven in Star Wars relating to the darkish facet of the Power’s affect on energy, the darkish facet would routinely advance somebody up that scale.

Associated

One Prequel Trilogy Scene Confirmed The Limits Of Anakin Skywalker’s Energy, Confirms Stunt Coordinator

Star Wars prequel trilogy stunt coordinator Nick Gillard confirms that one essential scene reveals the true restrict of Anakin Skywalker’s energy!

Primarily based on that scale, Anakin and Obi-Wan would even have been considerably evenly matched when it comes to ability throughout their battle on Mustafar, every touchdown someplace round a 9. The constraints of the darkish facet had been nonetheless at play, although. Anakin could have gotten that increase, however he was nonetheless appearing from a spot of hate, anger, and aggression, all of which lowered his rationality, inflicting him to make silly strikes such because the soar towards Obi-Wan when he had the excessive floor.

Comparisons between Obi-Wan and Anakin finally can’t be black-and-white, which is why that they had such unimaginable battles all through Star Wars. Anakin possessed immense energy, particularly as soon as he joined the darkish facet (earlier than he wanted the Darth Vader swimsuit), however Obi-Wan stays some of the disciplined Jedi in all of Star Wars. Even so, Obi-Wan Kenobi remained extra expert than Anakin Skywalker, made clear by his constant victories.