Tim Allen’s latest present, Shifting Gears, has its Rotten Tomatoes rating revealed. Debuting on ABC from creators Mike Scully and Julie Thacker Scully and showrunner Michelle Nader, the story of Shifting Gears follows the connection between Matt (Allen) and his daughter (performed by WandaVision and 2 Broke Ladies star Kat Dennings). Matt is a widowed proprietor of a automobile restoration store who lets his daughter, Riley, and his grandchildren transfer again in regardless of some sophisticated historical past. It airs on Wednesdays at 8 PM ET, with episodes streaming the following day on Hulu.

Shifting Gears has acquired a Rotten Tomatoes rating, revealing that the brand new collection is off to a tough begin. The sitcom at the moment holds a 44% score based mostly on 9 opinions, with 5 listed as unfavorable and 4 listed as optimistic. The rating breaks down to three.30 out of 10 stars, indicating that the unfavorable opinions are notably sharp. The rating will fluctuate as extra opinions are available in. Shifting Gears season 1 has a blended document in comparison with Allen’s well-known TV comedies, coming in forward of Final Man Standing season 1 (14%) however effectively behind Residence Enchancment‘s debut 12 months (64%).

What Do The Opinions Say About Shifting Gears?

It is A Acquainted Allen Premise

With a forged that features Seann William Scott, Daryl “Chill” Mitchell, Maxwell Simkins, and Barrett Margolis, with Brenda Track and Jenna Elfman in visitor roles, the appearing in Shifting Gears acquired stable suggestions from critics. Dave Nemetz of TVLine writes: “It’s constructed surprisingly effectively, with plenty of the credit score going to co-star Kat Dennings, who proves she will go toe-to-toe with Allen and match him jab for jab.” However the place the present falters for some is precisely what would make it attraction to others; it is much like Allen’s previous work.

That is made express in Daniel Feinberg’s assessment for The Hollywood Reporter as he writes “I watched Shifting Gears considering that it was Final Man Standing with out the center to return proper out and simply be Final Man Standing.” The assessment additionally cites that the appearing is succesful, although the premise and energy are missing. It is value noting that critics have solely screened two episodes, that means that the present may evolve with extra time. However, for now, for higher or worse, it is precisely what’s marketed.

Is Shifting Gears At Least Humorous?

The Comedy Additionally Falters.

Greater than any similarities to Allen’s earlier comedies, a key sticking level is that the primary two episodes usually are not all that humorous. The humor is dinged by going for the bottom widespread denominator and favoring straightforward laughs. This may occasionally mirror that Shifting Gears continues to be on the level the place it is introducing the characters and establishing their dynamics. Nevertheless it may additionally imply that the ABC present would not plan to develop past what its viewers expects it to be.

Associated

10 Most Anticipated New & Returning Community TV Exhibits Of 2025, From Fits L.A. To Will Trent Season 3

Quite a few new reveals and season premieres are making their solution to community tv in 2025, together with the extremely anticipated Fits spinoff.

In his assessment for IndieWire, Ben Travers offers Shifting Gears a D+ and writes that it “wants higher jokes, higher timing, higher arcs, higher set design (the kitchen seems like a Residence Depot show room), and higher use of its stars.” The truth that the sitcom would not make higher use of its ensemble is a recurring theme, with American Pie alum Sean William Scott highlighted as somebody the preliminary episodes do not make a lot of. His character, Gabriel, seems to be arrange for a romance with Riley. Albeit, to date, he’s the lovable doofus.

In a extra optimistic assessment, Alison Herman writes for Selection and underlined the present’s emotional middle by noting partially: “The excellent news is that there’s much more for Shifting Gears to mine on this area.” The collection, on this early stage, is about how Riley and Matt transfer ahead now that there is not any mother and spouse to behave as a peacemaker between them. The sitcom may very well work higher in its extra honest and emotional moments than its humor early on, although it stays one thing that viewers would possibly doubtlessly need to look ahead to within the early episodes.

Our Take On Shifting Gears

It Could Not Be Unhealthy To Know What You are Getting

Allen’s newest doesn’t appear to be clicking with critics, though it is just in the beginning. There may be additionally a artistic change, with Nader taking on as showrunner after the pilot episode. So it may nonetheless be the case that the brand new sitcom finds its groove after the premiere. Nader turned the showrunner after the collection creators exited in July 2024, earlier than the present’s premiere. Nader, a veteran tv author and producer, beforehand labored with Dennings on 2 Broke Ladies and the short-lived Hulu collection Dollface.

However even when it would not get there, a well-known comedy that’s simply nice sufficient and lifted by good performances can go the gap. For a lot of, that is precisely what Residence Enchancment and Final Man Standing had been. Each would go on to have lengthy runs, eight and 9 seasons, respectively. Each are well-liked, if not precisely extremely regarded, so there are worse fates for Shifting Gears.

Supply: Rotten Tomatoes

Your modifications have been saved

My Record

My Favourite TV Exhibits
My Watchlist

Matt, a widowed and cussed proprietor of a traditional automobile restoration store, has his life turned the other way up when his estranged daughter, Riley, and her teenage youngsters transfer in with him.

Launch Date

January 8, 2025

Character(s)

Matt
, Riley
, Ed
, Carter
, Georgia

Seasons

1

Broaden