In the case of vacation classics, there are few movies extra beloved or revered than It’s a Fantastic Life. Regardless of almost 80 years having handed since its debut, Frank Capra’s masterpiece continues to encourage generations with its deep themes, memorable characters, and heartwarming story. Nevertheless, the story of George Bailey (Jimmy Stewart) wasn’t successful with all who noticed it at first, particularly when it got here to the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Launched on the top of Joseph McCarthy’s tumultuous blacklisting, It’s a Fantastic Life turned the topic of an investigation that claimed it to be harmful propaganda.

‘It’s a Fantastic Life’s Writers Induced Suspicion

It’s a Fantastic Life has definitely transcended the generations, and it’s simple to see why. When George Bailey considers taking his personal life, an angel desperate to earn his wings, Clarence (Henry Travers), exhibits George what the world would have been like had he by no means been born. Regardless of being based mostly in darkness, the image’s heartwarming ending has develop into iconic and synonymous with the spirit of the vacation season. Along with being a field workplace success, and incurring a number of Oscar nominations, the film was inducted into the Nationwide Movie Registry by the Library of Congress in 1990. However for all its accomplishments, the movie did appeal to the eye of the FBI.

In accordance with the Washington Publish, Communist-hunting brokers, engaged on behalf of J. Edgar Hoover’s administration appeared on the movie as a “Computer virus” looking for to sneak “anti-American propaganda” to the lots. The hunt for alleged communist beliefs hidden inside motion pictures started in 1942 and lasted by way of 1958. As such, many people inside the movie business, in addition to greater than 200 movies, had been investigated for potential communist ties. A report written by a particular agent notes the group’s findings for a lot of movies, together with It’s a Fantastic Life. The piece claims that two of the film’s writers, Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett had been “very near recognized Communists and on one event within the latest previous … virtually lived with recognized Communists and had been noticed consuming luncheon every day with such communists as [screenwriter] Lester Cole.” It is very important be aware that Goodrich and Hackett had been by no means discovered responsible of becoming a member of the communist get together. With such suspicion, although, the movie itself was considered and regarded for potential blacklisting, and the agent’s findings weren’t a lot kinder.

The FBI Claimed ‘It’s a Fantastic Life’ Was Communist Propaganda

It’s a Fantastic Life could also be a largely heartwarming image, however the FBI’s unnamed agent who wrote the aforementioned report on the piece didn’t see it that method. Starting with the movie’s villain, Henry F. Potter (Lionel Barrymore), the report claimed that It’s a Fantastic Life “represented a moderately apparent try and discredit bankers.” The report continued by saying Potter was “‘Scrooge-type’ in order that he can be probably the most hated man within the image.” Naturally, this can be a shallow learn of the movie’s precise intent. In spite of everything, Potter is a thief and the individuals of Bedford Falls wouldn’t appear so great had they not come to George’s help. It’s not solely one of many image’s biggest scenes, it’s what makes the movie work as an entire.

The reporter prompt that Mr. Potter ought to have been portrayed as “following the principles as laid down by the State Financial institution Examiners in reference to making loans.” In fact, this eliminates any type of stakes, and subsequently plot, for the movie. Potter and the portrayal of bankers weren’t the one points the report comprises, additionally stating that the movie “intentionally maligned the higher class, trying to indicate the individuals who had cash had been imply and despicable characters.” As soon as once more, this utterly misses the purpose, because the movie’s ethical facilities on the significance of life, regardless of how small it could appear. Nonetheless, the report was written, and it was as much as the Home Un-American Actions Committee to determine what to do concerning the image.

‘It’s a Fantastic Life’ Didn’t Obtain A lot Consideration After the Investigation

Although the report painted a scathing portrait of It’s a Fantastic Life, little motion was really taken as soon as it was within the palms of the Home Un-American Actions Committee. Certainly, regardless of many movies and stars of the time being put underneath scrutiny, Smithsonian Journal states that HUAC determined to not take motion in opposition to the image or these concerned in its making. Not a lot is called to why the HUAC determined to not take motion, however the irony of the entire state of affairs is that every little thing that made the movie “subversive” is what makes it such an important piece of cinema. George and Mary (Donna Reed) are actually one of many biggest display {couples} of all time, and their journey stays one of many biggest ever instructed.

It is a Fantastic Life is obtainable to hire on Amazon Prime within the U.S.

Watch Now