The Purple Marriage ceremony is without doubt one of the greatest tragedies in Recreation of Thrones, and the HBO collection makes a number of adjustments to the e-book’s model of occasions. The outcomes are the identical: Robb and Catelyn Stark are betrayed and killed, giving the Lannisters a leg up within the Conflict of the 5 Kings — and rendering Home Stark’s future bleaker than earlier than. Nonetheless, one of many adjustments made to the Music of Ice and Fireplace books‘ Purple Marriage ceremony scene has to do with Robb Stark’s ultimate phrases. They’re completely different in each iterations of the incident, and the excellence is necessary.

Though Robb’s expertise on the Purple Marriage ceremony is devastating in Recreation of Thrones, one concept concerning the books someway manages to make his destiny even worse. The HBO present eliminates the opportunity of this concept proving true, as it alters the very last thing Robb says earlier than he is stabbed by Roose Bolton. It is sensible, as Recreation of Thrones leaves out a Home Stark storyline that is rather more outstanding within the books. Due to that, this concept would not work in HBO’s adaptation.

Recreation Of Thrones Modifications Robb Stark’s Final Phrases – What They Are In The Books

He Says “Gray Wind” In The Books, However “Mom” In The Present

In Recreation of Thrones season 3, episode 9, Robb Stark utters one final phrase earlier than Roose Bolton plunges a dagger into him: “Mom.” This line is directed at Catelyn Stark, who’s doing her finest to avoid wasting her eldest little one, regardless of the bloodbath unfolding earlier than them. It isn’t fully clear what Robb desires to convey to Catelyn earlier than he dies, as he by no means finishes his sentence. There are a number of methods to interpret this line, from Robb looking for consolation or forgiveness to Robb asking Catelyn to again down and cease providing her life for his.

The latter is the way it comes off in A Storm of Swords, although the supply materials does not play out exactly the identical manner. Though Robb says “Mom, no…” in response to Catelyn’s provide — and “Mom” once more after — his true ultimate phrases are “Gray Wind.” With Gray Wind separated from Robb throughout the Purple Marriage ceremony, it is not fully clear why he calls out for his direwolf on this second. It is potential he is hoping Gray Wind will present as much as save him. One concept posits one other clarification: that Robb wargs into Gray Wind throughout his ultimate moments in A Storm of Swords.

By Altering This Second, Recreation Of Thrones Prevented One Wild Purple Marriage ceremony Idea

Robb Would possibly Have Warged Into Gray Wind Throughout The Incident

A Purple Marriage ceremony concept that is made the rounds since A Storm of Swords debuted means that Robb warged into Gray Wind earlier than he died, basically transferring his consciousness to the direwolf. Though Recreation of Thrones nixes ASOIAF‘s warg storyline, it pops up in lots of the Starks’ chapters in George R.R. Martin’s books. It is most outstanding with Bran, Jon, and Arya, however all of the Stark siblings have the potential to warg, or enter and management their wolves.

Associated

Each Stark’s Recreation Of Thrones Character Arc, Ranked Worst To Finest

The Starks are a number of the most compelling characters in Recreation of Thrones, however a few of their character arcs are considerably higher than others.

That is much less explored with Robb, as we by no means see a warging dream throughout considered one of his POV chapters. Nonetheless, Martin confirmed that every one the Starks are able to warging, and the books drop hints to counsel as a lot. This places Robb calling out to Gray Wind in a brand new gentle, because it means he may need used his ultimate moments to shift into his thoughts. We all know from A Dance With Dragons that somebody can stay out one other life as a warg. Nonetheless, Robb clearly does not, so this concept would simply make the Purple Marriage ceremony extra tragic than it already is.

Robb Warging Into Gray Wind Someway Makes The Books’ Purple Marriage ceremony Even Worse

This ASOIAF Idea Simply Means Robb Died Twice

Whereas it could be attention-grabbing to be taught that Robb unlocks his warging talents throughout his ultimate moments, this revelation would simply make the books’ model of the Purple Marriage ceremony worse. Robb warging into Gray Wind would imply he dies twice within the supply materials, as Gray Wind does not outlive the eldest Stark sibling for very lengthy. Gray Wind’s dying is barely completely different in A Storm of Swords than it’s in Recreation of Thrones, as we’re instructed he takes down a number of Frey males earlier than he is killed. The end result stays the identical although: Gray Wind perishes proper after Robb and Cat.

Which means that Robb must face dying by the hands of individuals he believed have been his allies twice, which is devastating to contemplate. It will give readers some consolation, realizing that he went down preventing contained in the thoughts of his direwolf. Nonetheless, that aid is overshadowed by the considered Robb believing he’d escaped his destiny, simply to fulfill it once more.

Associated

8 Errors Robb Stark Made That Led To The Purple Marriage ceremony In Recreation Of Thrones (& The Books)

Robb Stark’s dying is without doubt one of the most upsetting in Recreation of Thrones, however his decision-making all through the warfare is what in the end results in this destiny.

Fortunately, Recreation of Thrones avoids this gut-wrenching hypothesis altogether. Chopping the warg storyline and altering Robb’s ultimate phrases render this concept an impossibility. It is secure to say Robb solely perishes as soon as within the HBO collection, simply as viewers can relaxation assured that Catelyn by no means returns as Woman Stoneheart. The finality of the Starks’ deaths is considerably comforting. Nonetheless, one Recreation of Thrones change nonetheless manages to make the present’s Purple Marriage ceremony worse than its e-book counterpart, simply otherwise.

to make its Purple Marriage ceremony sadder than its e-book counterpart.

Recreation Of Thrones Made Robb Stark’s Purple Marriage ceremony Destiny Sadder In A Totally different Manner

Together with Talisa & Robb’s Unborn Baby In The Scene Is Worse Than ASOIAF

Robb could not face the opportunity of two deaths in Recreation of Thrones, however he is compelled to observe the girl he loves die in entrance of him — one thing that does not occur in Martin’s books. Jeyne Westerling, who’s Robb’s love curiosity within the supply materials (she’s changed by Talisa within the present), is not current for the Purple Marriage ceremony in ASOIAF. Though Robb’s marriage to her continues to be on the coronary heart of the Starks’ battle with the Freys, she is not compelled to undergo the implications of his selections. She additionally by no means will get pregnant together with his little one, eradicating one other sufferer from the books’ story.

Talisa is killed whereas pregnant with Robb’s little one in Recreation of Thrones, making certain that the present’s Purple Marriage ceremony continues to be lots devastating, even with out the implications of Robb’s “Gray Wind” line. As Talisa is the primary individual stabbed within the HBO collection, Robb is compelled to observe as his spouse dies in entrance of him. That is in all probability worse than contending together with his personal dying twice, particularly realizing the longer term they might have had collectively. Subsequently, Recreation of Thrones nonetheless delivers an enormous emotional blow with Robb’s ending, which is why “The Rain of Castamere” stays so memorable to today.

Recreation Of Thrones

10/10

Launch Date

2011 – 2019-00-00

Showrunner

David Benioff, D.B. Weiss

Administrators

David Nutter, Alan Taylor, D.B. Weiss, David Benioff