On the finish of the final live-action Transformers film, Transformers: Rise of the Beasts, an enormous trace at the way forward for the franchise was dropped that set social media on fireplace: a crossover with the G.I. Joe franchise. It may have been a type of setups that by no means come to fruition, however the crossover has since been confirmed. Lorenzo di Bonaventura, in an interview with Collider‘s personal Steve Weintraub, states that the subsequent live-action enterprise for both franchise will, certainly, be that crossover. There is definitely nice curiosity in it, and there’s precedent for the pairing of the 2 blockbuster franchises (Marvel had a crossover collection in 1987). However is it what the franchise wants proper now? Is it what both franchise wants proper now? The reply is a definitive, albeit disappointing, no.

A Transformers/G.I. Joe Crossover Hasn’t Been Earned

As you may recall, following their profitable combat towards the Terrorcons and their grasp, Unicron (Colman Domingo, taking on from the late Orson Welles), the Autobots proclaim Earth as their new residence, given they’re unable to return to Cybertron. Noah Diaz (Anthony Ramos), again to the trials of regular life after saving the world, lands an interview for a safety job. However, lo and behold, that is no regular safety job however an invite to hitch the key navy group G.I. Joe.

It was a second that was legitimately shocking and well-received, to say the least, however it is not what is required proper now. Moreover, it hasn’t even been earned. Transformers is admittedly solely beginning to get good now, with the final three movies — Bumblebee, Transformers: Rise of the Beasts, and Transformers One — all correcting the course for the franchise. Nevertheless, whereas the movies have fared higher critically (Bumblebee is the bot to beat at 91%, with Transformers One at 89%), that hasn’t translated on the field workplace, the place Transformers: Rise of the Beasts has the bottom earnings of the live-action movies, whereas Transformers One narrowly beat out the iconically dangerous Joker: Folie à Deux.

G.I. Joe has fared even worse. Whereas the primary two movies did not fare too badly on the field workplace, the third, Snake Eyes: G.I. Joe Origins, introduced in simply shy of $30 million, nearly 80% lower than G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra‘s $150 million. Critically, the franchise has been a catastrophe, with G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra sitting at 33% on Rotten Tomatoes, G.I. Joe: Retaliation at 29%, and Snake Eyes at 35%. The G.I. Joe franchise hasn’t even discovered a course that is common, not to mention above it, and has been at a full cease since 2021.

If You are Gonna Do a Transformers/G.I. Joe Crossover, Do It Proper

Logically, which has by no means been a powerful swimsuit of film studios at the most effective of occasions, transferring forward with a Transformers/G.I. Joe crossover movie goes to go one in all two methods. In state of affairs one, the strengths of the Transformers franchise elevate G.I. Joe, overcoming no matter perceived obstacles there could also be and making a crap-ton of cash. In state of affairs two, G.I. Joe drags Transformers down, with the latter solely simply now constructing a stronger footing, and is unfold too skinny to assist the load of each franchises. The almost certainly is the second, a movie that makes cash, however sells its soul, these issues that labored so properly in Bumblebee and Transformers One, to do it.

Nevertheless it’s unlikely that the opinion of yours really goes to stop the crossover movie from taking place instantly, so to cite Wham!’s 1985 hit “I am Your Man,” “If you happen to’re gonna do it, do it proper.” The story cannot be this massive world-is-coming-to-an-end apocalyptic occasion that brings the 2 forces collectively, however one thing extra grounded, one thing that enables them to construct actual chemistry earlier than being thrown into no matter menace they’re up towards. The previous simply turns into a bombastic, formulaic action-adventure that each franchises have been saddled with earlier than, the place the latter builds on what made Bumblebee so efficient, an earned chemistry between Hailee Steinfeld‘s Charlie and Bumblebee. Nor can the characters they select to incorporate be interchangeable. It is onerous to spend money on characters when you’ll be able to’t inform who’s who or, worse, even care. There’s solely a handful in every franchise which are straightforward to establish, however in any other case, it simply seems to be like generic robots and troopers combating generic robots and troopers. Make us care, like how Transformers One added an emotional perspective largely lacking from the live-action movies.

Within the aforementioned interview with Collider, di Bonaventura is definitely saying the fitting issues, so at the very least publicly, it feels like they’re aiming in the direction of simply what we’re speaking about right here. After all, there’s a number of films which have promised nice issues that did not ship, so till the movie hits theaters, we merely do not know. And as G.I. Joe has taught us, “Realizing is half the battle.”

Transformers: Rise of the Beasts is accessible to stream within the U.S. on Paramount Plus

WATCH ON PARAMOUNT PLUS