Gilmore Ladies is greater than only a present—it’s a way of life, a faith.

Which is why many years after the present premiered in 2000, followers are nonetheless debating which boyfriend of Rory’s (Alexis Bledel) is greatest for her: the dangerous boy Jess Mariano (Milo Ventimiglia) who stole her coronary heart with a shared love of studying, fellow Yale scholar and grandparent-preferred alternative Logan Huntzberger (Matt Czuchry), or her past love Dean Forester, performed by Jared Padalecki.

However because it seems, Jared himself has a take that may shock followers.

“What staff am I?” the Supernatural alum teased to E! Information at Metal Metropolis Comedian Con. “All proper, I am Crew Jess. I’m.” (For extra from Jared’s interview, watch E! Information August 12.)

But, he isn’t the one former Gilmore Ladies boyfriend who has an surprising opinion.

“Humorous sufficient,” Jared continued, “Milo’s a buddy and he is Crew Dean. Someone despatched me a meme, when he received in his workplace in his home, he has his Emmy nomination alert letter and on the underside nook, it is like ‘Crew Dean eternally.’ And so I drew my very own ‘Crew Jess eternally’ with markers, like similar Milo, samesies however for you.”