When books are tailored to the massive display, it is a well-established indisputable fact that not each single minor element goes to get an opportunity to make the transition, typically as a consequence of time constraints or to keep away from overcomplicating the story. This method is completely regular and is just about anticipated so far as book-to-movie diversifications go. In fact, it occurred rather a lot with the Harry Potter books and flicks.

A number of the most essential issues omitted of the movies are what occurs to a number of the characters following the occasions of the story. These characters all seem within the film, however whether or not or not they lived or died on the finish is up within the air and may solely be answered by studying the novels. These are the Harry Potter characters whose destiny was left ambiguous within the motion pictures for one cause or one other.

10 Vincent Crabbe

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Thinker’s Stone’ (2001)

Vincent Crabbe (Jamie Waylett) is one among Draco Malfoy’s (Tom Felton) cronies who just about at all times accompanies him. Within the novels, he is not a lot of a big presence till the finale, when he unleashes Fiendfyre and by chance burns himself to a crisp within the course of. Clearly, he does not survive this, a lot to the horror of his buddies, who watch him die proper in entrance of them.

Nonetheless, within the live-action motion pictures, Crabbe’s destiny is left unsure as a result of the actor, Jamie Waylett, had run into some authorized bother in actual life and was subsequently fired from the movies following the fifth installment. He was then changed by Blaise Zabini (Louis Cordice), however the filmmakers felt that having Blaise take up the identical position as Crabbe would not really feel fairly proper. As such, they assigned Crabbe’s position to Gregory Goyle (Josh Herdman), one other one among Malfoy’s cronies who had been current since day one. Within the remaining movie, it’s Goyle who makes use of Fiendfyre and burns himself to loss of life within the course of, whereas no point out of Crabbe is made.

9 Dolores Umbridge

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix’ (2007)

Dolores Umbridge (Imelda Staunton) is by far some of the despised characters within the Harry Potter motion pictures, making her first look because the Defence Towards the Darkish Arts instructor in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. She is understood for her weird and uptight guidelines and insurance policies, denying the return of the Darkish Lord as per her position on the Ministry, and her merciless and strange strategies of punishment.

Umbridge seems in later movies, the place she maintains her job on the Ministry and begins persecuting the harmless on behalf of the Darkish Lord. She is probably not a full-on Dying Eater, nevertheless it’s actually no secret that she was an enormous fan of them. What occurs to her after the battle’s finish is not actually explored within the motion pictures, however within the books, Umbridge is tried and despatched to Azkaban for her crimes in opposition to the Wizarding World. It’s unknown how lengthy she stayed behind bars, however there is no denying that she undoubtedly acquired what she deserved.

8 Colin Creevey

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques’ (2002)

Colin Creevey (Hugh Mitchell) is an eccentric but enthusiastic younger boy who first seems in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques. He’s seldom seen with out his signature digital camera and is likely one of the many college students who turn out to be petrified upon his encounter with the Basilisk. Colin finally recovers however doesn’t make any follow-up appearances within the movies, which may be for the very best as a result of his story is far more tragic within the books.

Within the novels, Colin makes a number of reappearances, along with his pleasure about realizing Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) by no means actually waning. He’s later current in the course of the Battle of Hogwarts within the remaining ebook, however sadly, he’s killed in fight, dropping his life to one of many many Dying Eaters besieging the citadel. Colin may be somewhat unusual, however he has been a beloved background character for ebook followers, so watching him meet his premature finish makes the ultimate confrontation sting somewhat bit extra. For higher or for worse, this destiny isn’t explored on the massive display.

7 Gilderoy Lockhart

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques’ (2002)

Gilderoy Lockhart (Kenneth Branagh) is the Defence Towards the Darkish Arts instructor in Harry’s second 12 months at Hogwarts. Lockhart was one thing of a star within the Wizarding World, identified for his varied magical feats and adventures. Solely, he was truly a complete fraud, and these tales had been taken from different wizards and witches who had their recollections wiped by Lockhart. Because of this, his educating abilities had been horrible.

In each the ebook and the film adaptation, he tries to erase the recollections of Harry and Ron (Rupert Grint) after they uncover his secret, however he stupidly makes use of Ron’s damaged wand for the reminiscence appeal. It backfires and erases Lockhart’s reminiscence utterly. Lockhart later reappears within the fifth novel in St. Mungo’s magical hospital, the place he’s bumbling round like an oaf with zero recollection of who he’s or what he is presupposed to be doing. Because of this, Lockhart turns into confined to the hospital for the remainder of his life, utterly unaware of any facet of his previous life. It is a bit of tragic irony that is not precisely undeserved, however nonetheless somewhat unhappy.

6 Igor Karkaroff

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Goblet of Hearth’ (2005)

Igor Karkaroff (Predrag Bjelac) is the Headmaster of Durmstrang, the Northern and Japanese European faculty of magic. He first seems in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Hearth as Durmstrang arrives at Hogwarts for the Triwizard Match. He’s type of intimidating however appears to be on good phrases with Professor Dumbledore (Sir Michael Gambon).

Nonetheless, Harry later finds out that Karkaroff was previously a Dying Eater, serving within the First Wizarding Battle on behalf of the Darkish Lord, although he appeared to have reconsidered his position within the battle. Nothing else is alleged about him within the motion pictures, however within the books, Karkaroff flees for his life upon discovering out that the Darkish Lord has returned and takes refuge in an remoted cabin within the woods. He survives right here for a complete 12 months earlier than the Dying Eaters kill him for his perceived betrayal, an occasion that’s only a passing point out within the books. Karkaroff was at all times a little bit of a morally gray character, so his loss of life does not precisely damage a lot, however it’s horrifying realizing how scared he was of Voldemort and the way good the Dying Eaters had been at monitoring down their enemies.

5 Stan Shunpike

First look: ‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’ (2004)

Stan Shunpike (Lee Ingleby) is the eccentric conductor of the Knight Bus, who transports Harry to the Leaky Cauldron previous to his third 12 months at Hogwarts. Stan is type of odd, positive, however there does not look like any actual malicious intent in him. Or is there? Within the motion pictures, he’s the conductor of the bus and nothing extra, showing in a single scene, and that is it.

Within the books, although, Stan has a way more sinister position, as he’s revealed to be a supporter of Lord Voldemort (Ralph Fiennes) and is pulling loads of strings for him behind the scenes. Following the top of the battle, Stan is placed on trial on the Ministry of Magic, however he pleads not responsible, claiming he was beneath the Imperius Curse the entire time. There isn’t any affirmation if his claims are even remotely true, however he was allowed to stroll free anyway and returned to his job as a conductor. It is a quite unremarkable destiny, however Stan additionally had earlier run-ins with the legislation in the course of the battle, so one can not help however surprise if he was mendacity or not.

4 Peter Pettigrew

First look: ‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’ (2004)

Maybe essentially the most important destiny omitted of the flicks is that of Peter Pettigrew (Timothy Spall), the Animagus who poses as Ron Weasley’s pet rat, Scabbers, for the primary three movies. Audiences will probably do not forget that within the fourth movie, Peter raises Voldemort from the lifeless, however with the intention to carry out the ritual, he has to chop off his personal hand as an providing. When Voldemort returns, he grants Peter a silvery new hand; unbeknownst to Peter, it comes with a particular enchantment.

In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Half 1, Dobby (Toby Jones) hits Peter with some form of beautiful spell, knocking him out. He’s by no means seen once more within the movies, although he seems to have survived. Within the books, nonetheless, Peter meets a way more violent finish. See, his shiny new hand was enchanted to strangle him if it ever detected a touch of hesitation in killing somebody, which is precisely what Peter did when he tried to kill Harry on this identical scene. Thus, the hand breaks freed from Peter’s management and chokes him to loss of life within the Malfoy manor’s basement. It is some of the brutal and violent deaths within the ebook, particularly contemplating how Harry tries to avoid wasting him, however the magic on the hand is simply too sturdy, and Peter suffers a protracted, sluggish, painful loss of life.

3 Kingsley Shacklebolt

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix’ (2007)

Kingsley Shacklebolt (George Harris) seems within the fifth movie as a background character who exhibits up at Harry’s home to take him to Grimmauld Place. He’s later current in the course of the struggle within the Ministry of Magic, the place he duels in opposition to the Dying Eaters and helps to rescue the Hogwarts college students who traveled there. Kinglsey then fights within the Battle of Hogwarts in opposition to the Dying Eaters, cementing himself as a serious member of the Order of the Phoenix.

Kingsley could have been loyal to the Ministry, however he additionally is aware of proper from mistaken and, most of the time, made the proper alternative when it got here to fight Voldemort. Within the motion pictures, he’s proven to have survived the battle, which he does within the ebook, too, however what occurs to him after that’s unknown. That’s except one had been to learn the ebook. Following the battle, Kingsley was appointed to be the following Minister of Magic and reportedly led to some much-needed adjustments to the group, a becoming future for him.

2 Percy Weasley

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Thinker’s Stone’ (2001)

Percy Weasley (Chris Rankin) is the third-eldest of the Weasley brothers and is in his higher years at Hogwarts when Harry first arrives. Percy is a person of order and is sweet at upholding requirements and guidelines, receiving the place of prefect at Hogwarts. Following his commencement, Percy joined his father in working for the Ministry of Magic. The distinction is that Percy was far more loyal to his job than he was to his household.

Within the movies, he makes a minor look in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix however is just not seen past that. Within the books, nonetheless, Percy comes again to his household dwelling and bodily disowns his household, informing his mom that he now not needs to be related to them as a result of Ministry’s denial of Harry’s claims that Voldemort returned. Because the Weasleys had been Harry’s buddies, Percy wished nothing to do with them, which devastates his mom. Nonetheless, he later returns to struggle in the course of the Battle of Hogwarts in opposition to the Dying Eaters, reconciling along with his household. He’s current when his brother, Fred (James Phelps), dies. Within the motion pictures, although, Percy by no means actually will get this redemption, which is type of unlucky, as film followers nonetheless bear in mind him as a traitor who cared extra concerning the Ministry than his household or buddies.

1 Buckbeak

First Look: ‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’ (2004)

Buckbeak is the beloved hippogriff that Harry meets throughout his Care of Magical Creatures lesson with Rubeus Hagrid (Robbie Coltrane). The most effective non-human Harry Potter characters, Buckbeak is infinitely expressive and emotional, which made followers fall in love with him nearly instantly. In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak is ready to be executed by the Ministry as a result of he (justifiably) attacked Draco.

Harry, Ron, and Hermione save him from execution, and as a token of thanks, Buckbeak assists them with rescuing Sirius Black (Gary Oldman). Within the motion pictures, he’s by no means seen once more, however within the books, Buckbeak later seems at Sirius’ home at Grimmauld Place, the place he’s given the bed room previously belonging to Sirius’ deceased mom. After Sirius dies within the fifth novel and following the top of the Second Wizarding Battle, Harry discovers that Sirius left Buckbeak to him, that means Harry turns into the authorized proprietor of Buckbeak. The circumstances are fairly tragic, however no less than Buckbeak got here to stay with an individual whom he knew and trusted.

NEXT: 10 Finest Harry Potter Friendships, Ranked