Warning! This text incorporates SPOILERS for Dexter: Authentic Sin season 1, episode 5 and Thanksgiving (2023).A darkish concept concerning the thriller killer in Dexter: Authentic Sin appears very believable after a 2023 horror film starring the doable assassin. The thriller of who killed Jimmy Powell in Dexter: Authentic Sin is shaping as much as be the present’s largest twist. There are solely a handful of recent characters within the forged of Dexter: Authentic Sin, which suggests there are only some potential killers to this point. Since characters like Angel Batista (James Martinez) and Maria LaGuerta (Christina Milian) are nonetheless round within the unique Dexter, there isn’t any method they may have killed Jimmy Powell.

Most of Dexter‘s serial killers even have some form of private connection to Dexter Morgan (Patrick Gibson), so it appears probably that Jimmy’s killer is already within the present. Regardless that there aren’t many prospects for who might have killed Jimmy, his demise stays a thriller even after the ending of Dexter: Authentic Sin episode 5. Now, nevertheless, a brand new fan concept might have cracked the case and uncovered Jimmy’s killer hiding in plain sight. The idea additionally appears very probably due to a very separate horror movie starring the identical actor.

Aaron Spencer Is Dexter: Authentic Sin Season 1’s Secret Villain – Fan Principle Defined

Captain Spencer Had The Means, Time, & Data To Kill Jimmy Powell

The one who killed Jimmy Powell could also be hiding in plain sight in Dexter: Authentic Sin, as a brand new concept asserts that it was Captain Aaron Spencer (Patrick Dempsey). A number of Reddit customers, like Shmullus_Jones, have hypothesized that since Spencer is not within the unique Dexter, and since his job because the captain of Miami Metro Murder successfully guidelines him out of any investigation, he might have kidnapped and killed Decide Powell’s son. The idea holds some water, as Spencer probably knew the Powells and will have simply satisfied Jimmy to come back with him, however there’s much more to the thought than that.

Associated

Dexter: Authentic Sin Reveals That Season 6’s Most Stunning Deb Twist Nearly Occurred 20 Years Earlier

Dexter’s season 6 finale featured one of many present’s largest twists for Dexter & Deb, however Authentic Sin season 1 reveals it virtually occurred method earlier.

As Dexter: Authentic Sin episode 4 confirmed, Spencer remains to be fairly offended about his spouse’s infidelity and their divorce. He is additionally been principally absent in his son’s life, which suggests Spencer has ample time exterior of labor to moonlight as a killer. Plus, his information of regulation enforcement would make it extraordinarily straightforward for Spencer to confuse the detectives of Miami Metro and put them on the cartel’s scent. If Spencer does show to be the killer, it will additionally current an ideal second of drama and stress between Harry (Christian Slater) and Dexter because the latter tries to persuade his father to let him kill Spencer.

Patrick Dempsey’s Killer Reveal In Thanksgiving Makes The Spencer Villain Principle Extra Doubtless

Dempsey Already Performed A Cop-Turned-Killer In Thanksgiving, & He May Do It Once more In Dexter

There’s one other piece of proof that means Captain Spencer could possibly be the killer in Dexter: Authentic Sin. In 2023’s Thanksgiving, Patrick Dempsey performed Sheriff Eric Newlon, who turned out to be John Carver, the film’s killer. The twist of Newlon’s true id was so stunning, and Dempsey performed each the regulation enforcement and assassin sides of his character so properly, that he might simply do it once more in Authentic Sin. It is even doable that Thanksgiving served as a form of proof of idea for Dempsey to be forged as each a police captain and a serial killer in Authentic Sin.

Spencer Being Authentic Sin’s Killer May Assist Remedy A Lacking Dexter Character Thriller

Captain Matthews Is Unusually Absent From Authentic Sin – Spencer Being A Killer May Convey His Character In

Maybe the perfect a part of Captain Spencer being the killer in Dexter: Authentic Sin is how properly it will clarify one noteworthy character’s absence. Captain Thomas Matthews (Geoff Pierson) must be in Authentic Sin, as he was in most of Dexter‘s eight seasons and was good buddies with Harry Morgan, however his function is at the moment being crammed by Spencer. If Spencer is the serial killer and Dexter winds up killing him, it will be the right technique to carry Matthews in and have him change Spencer as Miami Metro’s captain. That twist would even work with Authentic Sin‘s early Nineteen Nineties setting.

There may be, in fact, all the time the likelihood that Captain Spencer will not show to be the primary villain of Dexter: Authentic Sin season 1. Different characters, like Tanya Martin (Sarah Michelle Gellar), even have proof suggesting they’re the killer, and the present might all the time introduce a yet-unnamed character as the true assassin. Authentic Sin might additionally introduce Matthews by both having Spencer retire or by having him be killed by the true assassin. In brief, although it is a pretty convincing concept, there isn’t any proof but that Captain Spencer is the true killer in Dexter: Authentic Sin.

• 

  Dexter: Authentic Sin explores the origins of Dexter Morgan as he transitions from pupil to serial killer in 1991 Miami. Guided by his father, Dexter channels his darkish urges by way of an ethical code whereas beginning a forensics internship on the Miami Metro Police Division.

• 

  Initially conceived as a parody trailer in 2007’s Grindhouse, Thanksgiving is a 2023 horror-slasher movie from director Eli Roth. The film facilities round a serial killer who heads to a small city in Massachusetts that creates an enormous occasion out of Thanksgiving every year with the intent of turning the residents into the primary course.