Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra gained fame over a decade in the past on 16 and Pregnant, documenting their heart-wrenching determination to put their first daughter, Carly, up for adoption. As one of many few teen dad and mom to take this path on the docu-style collection, their story deeply resonated with viewers, so it was no shock once they had been solid in Teen Mother.

Quick ahead to immediately, and the couple continues to share their lives on Teen Mother: The Subsequent Chapter, showcasing milestones like their marriage and the births of their three youthful daughters. But, a lot of their narrative nonetheless focuses on the adoption and their struggles with Carly’s adoptive dad and mom, Brandon and Teresa Davis. Whereas their frustration could also be comprehensible, the way in which they’ve aired grievances publicly might threat inflicting extra hurt than good—particularly for Carly.

Why Catelynn and Tyler Are Annoyed With Carly’s Adoptive Mother and father

Through the years, Catelynn and Tyler have brazenly expressed dissatisfaction with their adoption association, which was initially arrange as an open adoption. Brandon and Teresa appeared on Teen Mother throughout Carly’s early years, however as Carly grew older, they selected to step again from the highlight. This shift in dynamics has grow to be a sore level for Catelynn and Tyler, who really feel that Brandon and Teresa are standing in the way in which of Carly having a relationship together with her organic dad and mom and siblings.

In Could, tensions boiled over when Catelynn revealed on social media that Brandon and Teresa had opted out of the annual go to that Catelynn and Tyler had come to anticipate. The Ashley’s Actuality Roundup studies that followers speculated concerning the causes behind this determination. Some pointed to Tyler’s controversial OnlyFans account, which he and Catelynn have publicly defended. Others consider the Davises are uncomfortable with how usually Catelynn and Tyler focus on the adoption on social media and TV.

By September, the scenario escalated additional when Catelynn disclosed that she’d been blocked by Brandon and Teresa. In a scathing put up, she defended herself, claiming she had solely been sending updates about Carly’s organic sisters and their household life.

She expressed her frustration, writing:

“Adoption is loopy. I’m blocked all due to me sending updates and photos of her sisters…how is that honest for Carly and her siblings? It’s unhappy for certain… However, makes me unhappy for the youngsters…all I can do is present Carly sooner or later how a lot I attempted.”

Tyler shortly got here to Catelynn’s protection following the backlash she obtained for revealing they’d been blocked. Whereas the couple has confronted criticism for persevering with to make their struggles with Brandon and Teresa public, they’ve insisted they’re doing it to make sure Carly has a file of their efforts. They’ve argued that by sharing their aspect, Carly will in the future see they tried to keep up a relationship and that it was Brandon and Teresa who finally prevented it.

Nonetheless, this method has solely deepened the divide between the households, leaving followers questioning whether or not holding the battle within the highlight is really in Carly’s finest curiosity.

There Are Dangers of Making Adoption Drama Public

Whereas Catelynn and Tyler have defended their determination to air these struggles on-line, the truth is, Carly’s perspective stays unknown. As a teen, it’s totally doable she has her personal emotions concerning the scenario—she would possibly even favor much less contact or might not wish to be within the public eye.

Adoption, significantly open adoption, comes with inherent complexities for the adoptee. Whereas openness can present helpful connections to organic roots, it could possibly additionally result in emotional strain. Adopted youngsters would possibly really feel torn between their adoptive and organic households, wrestle with id points, or really feel overwhelmed by expectations to keep up relationships. Carly might even understand updates about her organic sisters as alienating somewhat than bonding.

Brandon and Teresa’s determination to reduce communication might very nicely stem from a need to guard Carly. They possible didn’t anticipate how huge Teen Mother would grow to be once they agreed to take part within the early seasons. Now, they might merely be making an attempt to present Carly a non-public, regular upbringing—free from the highlight and the drama that inevitably comes with public airing of household grievances.

Catelynn and Tyler Ought to Prioritize Privateness Over Public Posts

By frequently posting about their frustrations, Catelynn and Tyler threat alienating not solely Brandon and Teresa but additionally Carly. The fixed public discourse could also be including pointless stress to an already delicate scenario. Adoption is difficult sufficient with out including a platform with thousands and thousands of viewers to the combo.

Many followers have criticized the couple’s determination to maintain airing these points on-line, noting that respecting Brandon and Teresa’s boundaries may be step one towards repairing their relationship.

By selecting privateness over public confrontation, Catelynn and Tyler might shift the main target again to what actually issues — Carly’s well-being. Taking issues offline would possibly give them a greater likelihood at re-establishing belief and communication together with her adoptive dad and mom and, ultimately, with Carly herself. Their precedence must be their daughter, not a story for social media or TV. Typically, staying quiet is the loudest method to present love.

Teen Mother: The Subsequent Chapter may be streamed on Peacock.

Watch on Paramount+